FAIRFIELD – Pomperaug’s late heroics saw the Panthers come back to defeat Notre Dame Prep in overtime, 27-20, securing a 9-1 regular season record and clinching a home playoff game.
Friday’s regular season finale featured a fourth-quarter comeback for the ages. Trailing 20-13 with less than a minute remaining on the clock, the Panthers faced third down from the Notre Dame Prep 15-yard line. Jack Guinipero made the halfback pass to Caleb McKee, who was double-covered in the end zone, but still made the play to tie the game at 20 following the successful extra point.
The Lancers (8-2) nearly won in regulation. A hail mary into Pomperaug territory would have put the home team inside the Panthers’ 5-yard line but was nullified by an offensive holding penalty. Their drive ultimately stalled, and Pomperaug took over on downs to force overtime.
In the extra session, Pomperaug got the ball first. Guinipero, who briefly exited the game due to cramps, ran in the 8-yard touchdown, and Jack Reeder’s extra point made it 27-20.
Notre Dame’s overtime possession ended when a fourth-and-goal pass from the 13-yard line fell incomplete, clinching the extra-time thriller for the Panthers.
“If there’s ever a good warm-up for the playoffs, this is it,” said Pomperaug head coach Tony Pereira following the win. “I can’t say enough about our kids. It’s incredibly satisfying to see them come through.”
First Half
Notre Dame Prep struck first, scoring on a screen pass from over 40 yards out on a three-play drive. The extra point failed, leaving the Lancers up 6-0 early.
Pomperaug answered on a five-play, 58-yard drive capped by Dom Creaco’s 2-yard touchdown run. The extra point put the Panthers up 7-6.
The remainder of the first half consisted of turnovers: Notre Dame Prep recovered a fumble and recorded an interception, while Pomperaug also recovered a fumble on defense. The Lancers also missed a field goal that would have put them ahead.
The half’s biggest stand came at the end, with the Panthers making a goal-line stand and stopping the Lancers on fourth-and-goal in the final seconds of the first half, keeping their one-point lead at the break.
Second Half
Notre Dame Prep’s Ja’cari Harris had a 24-yard rushing score to put the Lancers up in the third quarter, and a two-point conversion made it a 14-7 game.
The Panthers answered with one of their signature run-heavy, smash-mouth drives that stretched into the fourth quarter, ending with Creaco’s second rushing touchdown of the game. Their two-point conversion attempt fell short, and they trailed 14-13 with nine minutes on the clock.
Notre Dame Prep quarterback JJ Studeny responded with a 10-yard touchdown run. However, with a 20-13 lead, the Lancers decided to go for a two-point conversion and failed to convert.
“We tried to put it out of their hands,” said Notre Dame Prep head coach John Johnson. “That was a coaching staff decision. The philosophy in that is to go up two scores. Hindsight is 20/20.”
That decision left the door open for Pomperaug to march down the field, with Guinipero leading the way in the comeback.
“I live for Pomperaug,” said Guinipero. “Every day before games, I am just thinking about community. The impact you can have on the community through high school football is just so immense.”
“Having a good football team brings pride to the community,” he added.
McKee, the recipient of the half-back pass that forced overtime, credited the team’s offensive line for their stout performance against a tough Notre Dame Prep team.
“It all starts in the trenches,” said McKee.
Pomperaug will host a Class MM playoff home game against an opponent yet to be determined.
Pereira quoted the late Chuck Drury following the game, saying, “That is Pomperaug football right there. You play the next play. That’s all I hear in my head from him.”

By Evan Triantafilidis



